<aside> 💡 Use case: an ad that worked starts working less because the same people have seen it too often. You keep paying for a tired picture. This playbook confirms it is the creative and not something else, builds fresh versions in Canva and lines up the rotation, ready for you to switch on.

</aside>

<aside> ⚡ What sets it off: the numbers on a running ad slide. You paste which ad, which channel and what the numbers show. It only counts as fatigue if it passes the rule you set in brand-os/reporting/kpi-model.md and nothing else on the ad changed in the same period.

</aside>

What happens, step by step

<aside> 🧩 Department on this card: Creative studio, with the rotation handed to Publishing & social, the only department that schedules.

  1. Orchestrator: checks the kill switch and the owner files, tests the fatigue rule and checks logs/activity.md for any other change to the ad.
  2. Creative studio (Canva): rebuilds the creative: new versions that keep the offer and message and change one thing each (image, headline or layout), checked against your visual specs.
  3. Publishing & social (Metricool): writes the rotation plan (which version replaces which, where, from when) and sets it up in Metricool as a draft only.
  4. Orchestrator again: queues the swap for you. </aside>

What it reads

File Why it matters
brand-os/reporting/kpi-model.md The fatigue rule
logs/activity.md Whether budget, audience, offer or landing page changed at the same time
brand-os/creative/visual-specs.md Sizes, colours, fonts and logo rules per placement
brand-os/creative/asset-library.md The only photos, fonts and logos allowed
brand-os/creative/video-scripts.md Script formats, for a video ad

Who approves what

<aside> 🛑 A running ad is paid spend, so the swap always waits for you.

The command file

<aside> 📋 Copy this into .claude/commands/ad-creative-fatigues.md.

</aside>

---
description: Playbook. An ad's creative is wearing out. Confirms the fatigue, rebuilds fresh creative in Canva and prepares the rotation in Metricool. The swap always waits for the owner.
argument-hint: "<which ad, which channel, and what the numbers show>"
---

# Playbook: ad creative fatigues

The event: $ARGUMENTS

## Before anything
1. If the file owner/STOP exists, stop. Append
   `YYYY-MM-DD HH:MM | orchestrator | stopped: owner/STOP present | -` to logs/activity.md
   and do nothing else.
2. Read owner/budget-cap.md, owner/approval-bar.md, owner/brand-voice.md and owner/positioning.md.
   They are read-only. If any still contains `[FILL IN:`, stop and tell the owner which file.

## Step 1. The orchestrator goes first
Use the orchestrator agent on this event as a playbook event
(priority: event, playbook: ad-creative-fatigues). It decides whether this is really
fatigue, then briefs Creative studio and Publishing & social.

## Worth acting on
It acts only if both are true:
1. The ad passes the fatigue rule in brand-os/reporting/kpi-model.md.
2. Nothing else changed on the ad in the same period (budget, audience, offer or landing
   page), according to logs/activity.md. If something did, the numbers are not about the
   creative.
If kpi-model.md sets no fatigue rule, do not guess one. The orchestrator adds an item to
queue/needs-your-ok.md asking the owner to set it, logs it and stops.
If it is not fatigue, it logs the reason and stops.

## Steps
1. Creative studio rebuilds the creative. Use the creative-studio agent on its brief. It reads
   brand-os/creative/visual-specs.md, asset-library.md and video-scripts.md (for a video ad),
   plus brand-os/brand-brain/voice-guide.md and tone-rules.md. It keeps the offer and the
   message, and builds the number of new versions the brief asks for in Canva, changing one
   thing per version (image, headline or layout) so Results & ROI can tell which one worked.
   It runs the spec check and saves drafts/YYYY-MM-DD-<channel>-<slug>-creative.md.
2. Run the orchestrator again on the return. It briefs Publishing & social with the versions.
3. Publishing & social prepares the rotation. Use the publishing-social agent on its brief.
   It writes which version replaces which, on which placement, from when, to
   drafts/YYYY-MM-DD-schedule-<slug>.md, and sets the rotation up in Metricool as a draft
   only. Until Metricool is connected, the plan is written ready to paste, marked [PASTE].
4. Run the orchestrator again. It queues the swap for the owner.

## Who approves
A running ad is paid spend, so the swap always waits for the owner. No exceptions.
- One item in queue/needs-your-ok.md, in the format at the top of that file, with the new
  versions and the rotation plan in the File line.
- If the swap would change the budget, the Spend line says so. If it would pass
  owner/budget-cap.md, the title says OVER CAP.
- The item also says if a version shows a real person, changes a claim or mentions a price
  or an offer.
Once the owner ticks Approve, the orchestrator briefs Publishing & social to switch the
rotation on in Metricool exactly as approved.

## Log
Every agent appends one line per action to logs/activity.md:
`YYYY-MM-DD HH:MM | <agent> | <action> | <file>`
Example: `YYYY-MM-DD HH:MM | creative-studio | rebuilt ad versions in Canva, spec check pass | drafts/YYYY-MM-DD-<channel>-<slug>-creative.md`

## What the owner sees at the end
- Fatigue or not, and the rule it was checked against
- The new versions and the one thing that changed in each
- The rotation plan
- The item in queue/needs-your-ok.md to tick

## Never
- Pause, swap or edit a live ad from this command.
- Change the budget, audience or offer. This playbook only replaces the creative.
- Use a photo, font or logo that is not in asset-library.md, or generate a real person's face.

Run it

<aside> ▶️ In Claude Code, from the project folder:

</aside>

/ad-creative-fatigues "<which ad, which channel, and what the numbers show>"

<aside> 📄 What you get back: fatigue or not and the rule it was checked against, the new versions with the one thing that changed in each, the rotation plan, and the item in the queue to tick.

</aside>

Example

<aside> ☕ Example (Northwind Coffee, a fictional brand): the Facebook ad for the bean subscription has been running with the same photo of a bag on a shelf, and its numbers have slid past the fatigue rule.

<aside> 👉 Next: DM or lead at 11pm

</aside>